I started writing this column while lying on the floor with a golden retriever
who didn't have long to live. All goldens are friendly and eager to please,
but Cody was especially affectionate and goofy. He loved to sit on park
benches and he seemed to think that everybody he met had nothing better to do
than pat him. Most people agreed.
Cody was only seven, middle-aged for the breed, but a fast-moving cancer was
filling up his lungs, making it harder and harder for him to breathe.
Cancer is all too common in dogs, especially golden retrievers: 60% of them
die of it, more than twice the average rate for all breeds. That includes
lymphoma, a cancer of the white blood cells; osteosarcoma, a cancer of the
bones, and hemangiosarcoma, a particularly nasty cancer of the cells that line
the blood vessels whose first symptom may be sudden death.
"A dog can be literally chasing a ball in the backyard, come in for a drink of
water and collapse and be dead within minutes," says Rhonda Hovan, research
facilitator for the Golden Retriever Club of America.
While it's tempting to see cancer as the Curse of the Golden Retriever, all
breeds have their health scourges. Bulldogs have respiratory problems;
dachshunds have back issues; Labrador retrievers have heart disease and
diabetes and even with a much lower rate of cancer, die at roughly the same
age as goldens.
It's difficult to avoid the hereditary risks, but now that the canine genome
has been sequenced, several research projects are under way to try to identify
genes that predispose dogs to such issues in the hopes that selective breeding
can avoid them. In the meantime, says Ms. Hovan, "The good news is that we
think there are a number of lifestyle choices that can reduce the cancer risk."
We bought Cody from a big breeder known in decades past for its champions, and
even as a puppy he turned heads. But as handsome as he was, he was dealt a bad
genetic hand. He was diagnosed with hip dysplasia at five months and epilepsy
at one year. And the genes for actually retrieving things never kicked in.
We'd throw a ball to Cody and he'd look quizzically, as if to say, "How about
just patting me instead?" It was hard to resist.
Since cancer is found in goldens all over the world, experts theorize that the
genetic predisposition goes back to the early founder dogs—in their case, a
yellow flat-coated retriever and a now-extinct type of water spaniel—that were
bred in the 1860s by a Scottish land baron who was seeking a superior sporting
dog. After several generations of refinements, the breed was officially
recognized by the U.K.'s Kennel Club in 1911, and the "studbook" was closed,
meaning that henceforth, all purebred goldens would be descended from the
existing dogs.
Many dogs die of cancer and it's difficult to avoid hereditary traits that
predispose some breeds. But there are lifestyle choices that can reduce a
pet's cancer risk and cancer treatments that can prolong life. Veterinarian
Dr. Leah Jackson talks with WSJ's Health Columnist Melinda Beck.
All purebred dogs are essentially inbred. And the genes become more
concentrated with each generation, because most pet dogs aren't bred and
breeders select only a few dogs with the most desirable traits to reproduce.
"It's possible that some trait that we desire in goldens is linked to
something that puts them at risk for cancer. We just don't know what it is,"
says Ms. Hovan, who has also bred goldens in Akron, Ohio, for the past 30 years.
Contrary to rumors in dog-runs and on the Internet, there's no evidence that
cancer is more prevalent in any particular line of golden or puppies by
popular sires, Mr. Hovan and other experts say. Cancer has been found in
"field" goldens with lean faces and dark coats as well as "show" goldens with
bigger builds, blocky heads and light coats.
Careful breeding decisions can greatly reduce the risk of other common
problems in the breed, including hip and elbow dysplasia, heart and eye
problems. But "we have no breeding tools at this time that seem to make any
difference in the rate of cancer in goldens," says Ms. Hovan.
"It's the breed that's predisposed to cancer, not any particular line," agrees
K. Ann Jeglum, a veterinary oncologist in West Chester, Pa., who has collected
pedigrees of more than 4,000 goldens and traced how lymphoma traveled through
the generations.
Susceptible Breeds
About 1 in 3 dogs die of cancer, about the same rate as people. Some breeds,
however, are more susceptible than others. Here are the breeds with highest to
lowest incidences of cancer. (Average life expectancy shown in parentheses.)
Highest Risk
* Boxer (10½ years)
* Golden retriever (12)
* Rottweiler (10)
* Bernese mountain dog (8)
High Risk
* Boston terrier (13 years)
* English bulldog (8)
* Scottish terrier (13)
* Cocker spaniel (12)
Average Risk
* Irish setter (12 years)
* Schnauzer (standard 12; miniature 15)
* Labrador retriever (12½)
* Mixed Breed
Lower Risk
* Beagle (13 years)
* Poodle (standard 12; miniature 15)
* Collie (12)
* Dachshund (15 1/2)
Part of the problem is that cancers usually develop after a dog is beyond her
breeding years and may have already produced many puppies, notes Wayne Jensen,
chief scientific officer for the Morris Animal Foundation. The non-profit
research organization is helping to fund several major projects aiming to find
genetic markers that could identify puppies prone to cancer well before they
are considered for breeding.
In one such study, co-sponsored by the Golden Retriever Foundationresearchers from three universities plan to collect tissue and blood samples from 150 goldens with lymphoma and 150 goldens with hemangiosarcoma and
compare them with blood samples from 300 older goldens who have remained
cancer free. Researchers will be looking not only for gene variations that
could predispose some dogs to cancer, but also for markers that could allow
for early detection and indications of how tumors respond to treatments.
Another research project aims to do for goldens what the Framingham Heart
Study has done for heart disease in people—that is, follow 1,000 or so healthy
dogs throughout their lives, evaluating genetic, nutritional and environmental
risk factors relate to cancer and other diseases.
Health Mailbox
Are mutts and crossbreeds less prone to cancer? Not necessarily, several
experts say. Some studies that have compared purebreds in general to mixed
breeds find about a 10% increase in lifespan for comparably sized mixed-breed
dogs. But there's no predicting what traits, and health problems, could show
up, and no one is keeping statistics.
Last fall, Cody's hip dysplasia was bad enough that he underwent surgery to
remove the arthritic, degenerated ball of his hip joint. Theoretically, the
muscles and tendons form a false but workable new joint. But instead of
returning to the joyful, energetic dog we'd known for seven year, Cody got
mysteriously weaker. Three months after the surgery, an X-ray revealed that
his lungs were filled with cancer that had metastasized from somewhere, though
we never found the origin.
To Join a Study
If your purebred golden retriever is diagnosed with cancer, providing a small
blood or tissue sample can help with ongoing research that may spare others
the same fate. Healthy goldens are also needed for comparison. See these
Websites for more information
*THE BROAD INSTITUTE
*BREEN LAB
*MODIAN LAB
* Contact Rhonda HovanRhondahovan@aol.com
For research on other canine cancers, see THE MORRIS ANIMAL FOUNDATION
Cody's cancer was too advanced to treat by the time we found it. But some
cancers in dogs do respond well to treatment when they are detected early.
Surgery, radiation or chemotherapy, alone or in combination, can buy months or
years for some dogs.
Last year, the Food and Drug Administration approved the first drug
specifically for canine cancer, Palladia, for use with mast cell tumors that
occur near the skin. Some of the same chemo drugs used in humans are used in
dogs, but side effects are usually milder; veterinary oncologists often aim to
give dogs a high quality of life for their remaining time rather than attempt
a long-odds cure.
Early warning signs include lumps or masses on or under the skin; which could
be signs of mass cell tumors; lethargy, vomiting, diarrhea, changes in
breathing or eating habits that could signal lymphoma; lameness or stiffness
could indicate osteosarcoma. But hemangiosarcomas have typically metastasized
long before they are detected. Ms. Hovan says one of her golden, Pete, who
hiked 8,000 miles by her side, died of hemangiosarcoma. "As experienced as I
am, I didn't know until 12 hours before she passed away."
While it's impossible to avoid the inherited risk of such cancers, there are
steps owners and breeders can take to reduce environmental factors that may
contribute.
As much as possible, owners should limit their dog's exposure to second-hand
smoke, pesticides and phenoxy herbicides, which have been linked to increased
risks of some canine cancers. (But contrary to some rumors, there's no
evidence linking flea- and tick-prevention products to elevated cancer risk.
One 2008 study even found that goldens treated with the "spot-on" type of such
products had significantly fewer lymphomas, though the reasons weren't clear.)
Just as with humans, keeping dogs lean and fit seems to lower their risk of
cancer, as well as bone, joint and other health problems. Owners and breeders
should be particularly vigilant during the first four months, Ms. Hovan says.
Many vets recommend following the "slow-grow" plan, which calls for golden
puppies to weigh just 9.5 pounds at eight weeks and 30 pounds at 20 weeks.
There is little evidence to support claims that extremely low-carb diets
reduce cancer risks. "It's not the kind of food that matters, it's the
amount," she says. But she does recommend giving dogs a half cup of raw
cruciferous vegetables—cauliflower, broccoli, Brussels sprouts and
cabbage—approximately three times a week. "Dogs don't generally chew their
food, so you have to puree it," she says.
I wish this story had a happier ending. Cody lasted only six weeks after his
cancer was diagnosed, and we never found out what kind it was. A needle
aspiration of his lungs was inconclusive, and we didn't want to subject him to
anything more invasive. Instead, we gave him as much time, and patting, as we
could. But it wasn't enough to repay the love he gave us.
Write to Melinda Beck at HealthJournal@wsj.com
********************************************************************************
*link to study listed below
More related cancer info:
Study Focuses on Cancer in Golden Retrievers
New $1 million study will examine the two most common cancers affecting the breed.
Posted: June 9, 2010, 2 a.m. EDT
Golden Retriever:
The Golden Retriever Foundation and Morris Animal Foundation
have launched a three-year, $1 million canine cancer study that will examine
cancers in Golden Retrievers. Titled "Discovery and Characterization of
Heritable and Somatic Cancer Mutations in Golden Retrievers," the study, which
is slated to begin this summer, is also dubbed the MADGiC Project (Making
Advanced Discoveries in Golden Cancers).
The aim of the study is to investigate mutations that are involved in risk and
progression of hemangiosarcoma and lymphoma, the two most common cancers
affecting Golden Retrievers. However, the research will also be of interest to
all dog owners since these cancers affect every breed.
Hemangiosarcomas are a type of cancer that arises in the blood system, forming
tumors that are highly malignant. Lymphoma is a form of cancer that can
rapidly spread through the lymph system.
The study will also seek to identify genes that predispose some dogs to cancer
so that breeders may someday be able to reduce cancer risk through breeding
selection. DNA tests may also be used for diagnosis and possibly to guide
treatment choices in the future, according to the two groups.
In addition, the study will investigate mutations that occur in the tumors
themselves and will profile the susceptibility of specific tumor types to
various chemotherapy compounds, which may lead to improved therapy options,
the two groups noted.
The Golden Retriever Foundation and Morris Animal Foundation expect that this
research may also directly benefit humans since the genes involved in cancer
are sometimes the same in dogs as in people.
The jointly funded project is part of Morris Animal Foundation's Canine Cancer
Campaign (www.curecaninecancer.org).
I would like to add one more worthy contact to this article, CHIC DNA Repository Steffi Mullins, Marithyme
|